Digital Natives are immersed in their media — and use this collective, connected immersion to maintain a state of digital attachment to whom and what they want, when and where they want it. Devices like iPods, laptops, and cell phones provide the platform for Immediates’ distributed presence.
For the Immediates, social and immersive media offer a collective medium of extended and augmented presence that makes me “more me,” rather than–as Digital Immigrants (“Animatiates”) view it–as a medium that offers a tempered, “low res” representation of me.
That’s why I find this “New Media fasting” movement so fascinating.
For the professors who are assigning these “fasts,” the hope is that, by unplugging them from their digital selves, they will spark a re-connection and renewed awareness of the impact of the devices on each student’s “real” selves.
Perhaps. But I think the fasts underestimate an important reality: Immediates’ sense of self — identity, attachment, efficacy — is not separate from the media each uses to create it; forcing Immediates to strip the media away will hinder, rather than help, each actualize and express his or her “real self” to you and to their peers.
As the story linked above notes, the anxiety of disconnect is overwhelming in a short period of time for many who try the fast. For some, it may be an issue of self-discipline. But it is also a result of the unique socialness of individual behavior — and, as a result, identity — that marks the Immediate generation. They are a widely-connected, uber-present generation; even seemingly simple, short-term disengagements seem unnatural. As one student noted after a few days of digital fasting:
My Mom thought I died.
Yes, the reality is that Immediates ARE their mediated selves. A day or two of digital fasting may offer a glimpse of life as folks “used to live it,” but likely won’t encourage many of them to stay disconnected. Just like a field trip to Colonial Williamsburg rarely sparks an interest in churning one’s own butter, New Media fasts likely will not induce a spike in Scrabble sales … just a bunch of stressed-out kids with overflowing Inboxes.